Eagle Rock pie contest brings neighbors together through baking

The Eagle Rock Pie Baking Contest at the Center for the Arts Eagle Rock  welcomed community members for an afternoon of pie tasting, friendly competition and neighborhood connection Nov. 14.

The contest featured several categories, including savory, sweet, vegan, gluten-free, store-bought and baked by kids. Attendees also had the opportunity to participate in the people’s choice category.

Amber Sealey, an Eagle Rock resident, actress, film producer and the organizer of the event, said she grew up in Santa Fe, New Mexico, where a similar tradition brought her family together. Sealey said the tradition started with her dad and neighbor as a way to decide who was the better baker.

“There was a really amazing crop of apricots in New Mexico that year, and my dad, who loves baking, and another neighbor across the way named Lucy, [who] also loves baking, got into a friendly argument about who made the best pie,” Sealey said. “So they [decided to] compete.”

Sealey said when she moved to Eagle Rock, she wanted to create a similar tradition for her new neighborhood. Sealey said she saw the event as a way to create stronger connections between residents.

“Having local community roots really strengthens all of us,” Sealey said. “So I was [thinking] this is something I can do. I can help create a tradition in my neighborhood.”

According to Sealey, the first pie baking contest in Eagle Rock started with neighbors gathering on the street, setting up tents and inviting friends. As the numbers of attendees increased, Sealey said she wanted to expand the event beyond her cul-de-sac.

“[The contest] just grew and grew each year […] Eventually [the contest] got to the place where I wanted this to be a whole neighborhood [thing]. I want it to benefit more people and I want the whole neighborhood to feel like they have ownership over it,” Sealey said.

Table of judges taste testing for the pie contest at The Center for the Arts Eagle Rock in Los Angeles, CA. Nov. 13, 2026. Lupin Nimberg/The Occidental

Alie Ward brought years of pie-tasting experience as a judge at this year’s contest. Ward said she previously worked for the Cooking Channel on a show called Unique Sweets, where she traveled around the country sampling different desserts.

“I was a judge the last time we had [the Eagle Rock pie contest],” Ward said. “It’s not a thankless job.”

Having previously worked for the event, Ward said she was excited to see it grow. According to Ward, the event offers the ability to make connections, discuss baking and find inspiration for the upcoming holidays.

“I am getting some really great ideas of other things that I’d want to try to make,” Ward said. “There’s all these neighbors […] and they’re getting to hang out, talk about their pie process, talk about what they like and maybe get some ideas for what to make for the holidays.”

Jarrett Sleeper, an Eagle Rock resident who designed the contest poster, said he wanted to incorporate the sense of connection that the event brings in the poster. Sleeper said he noticed that the shape of Eagle Rock resembled the top of a pie.

“I knew I wanted to make a big pie but then when I went and looked at the picture of the Eagle Rock, I was like ‘hey that looks like the top of the pie,’” Sleeper said. “So that’s the actual Eagle Rock. Also I never realized until doing it and looking at these classic images people have […] it’s the shadow that makes this eagle shape.”

Sleeper said one of the things he appreciates most about living in Eagle Rock is the relationships he has developed with those around him. Sleeper said events like the pie contest help create a sense of belonging that expands beyond simply recognizing faces.

“I’ve never lived anywhere in LA where I know all my neighbors, and [here] we pretty much know all of our neighbors,” Sleeper said. “That kind of feeling is very rare in LA and maybe more and more of the world in general.”

Amber Sealey and Jarrett Sleeper at the pie contest at The Center for the Arts Eagle Rock in Los Angeles, CA. Nov. 13, 2026. Lupin Nimberg/The Occidental

Elizabeth Pan, a neighborhood resident, said she has participated in every single Eagle Rock pie baking contest. Pan said the event has encouraged her to experiment with new recipes.

“I really liked what I made last year, which was this veggie, curry, savory pie, and it won best savory because not many people make savory pies,” Pan said. “But I learned that from the previous year. I intentionally made a savory pie to increase my chances.”

For Sealey, the competition is about more than the pies themselves. Sealey said she hopes the love she feels for her neighbors can grow street by street, no matter their differences.

“We are a very diverse group, in all different ways, socioeconomically, racially [and in our] personalities, and we all love each other.”

Contact Gray Sheridan at gsheridan@oxy.edu

Loading

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Read more

Latest articles